Showing posts with label FTTN. Show all posts
Showing posts with label FTTN. Show all posts
As the NBN is nearing closer to being awarded, a report has been compiled in the United States about the prospects of take up by the community if a similar rollout was to occur.
The Obama administration has already committed $US6b (A$10b) to the expansion of Fibre to the Home in regional America, and when Obama was a Senator he co-sponsored the 100Mbit nation - a strategy to rollout 100Mbps to the majority of the United States.
The report, released yesterday by Pew Internet and American Life Project found that even if high-speed Internet service was available to the entire nation, about one-third of Americans not currently using broadband still wouldn't because of the expense.
The report was based on two surveys of 4,254 people last year and illustrates a potential hang-up in President Obama's goal to bring broadband Internet to rural and other under served areas: If they build it, it's not clear that people will come.
Will the same apply to regional Australia? The Rudd government has been pushing a rollout to 98% of households and business in Australia, which could add significant cost to the rollout. If only a 66% take up is achieved can the networks be rollout out and achieve its financial goals. In my opinion the target should have been 87% which would have covered the top 50 cities in Australia.
"There are multiple reasons why people don't have broadband, and the hope is that if you are a policymaker you would take away from this report that a focus on availability and price will only get you part of the way there," said John Horrigan, an associate director of research at the Pew project and author of the report.
The nonprofit group One Economy has urged lawmakers to include provisions in a stimulus plan that would renovate public housing so that all units in a building would have access to a shared data network, thereby reducing monthly costs per home by several dollars a month. Rey Ramsey, chief executive of One Economy, said prices of about $10 or less per month is the threshold for greater adoption.
The Obama administration has already committed $US6b (A$10b) to the expansion of Fibre to the Home in regional America, and when Obama was a Senator he co-sponsored the 100Mbit nation - a strategy to rollout 100Mbps to the majority of the United States.
The report, released yesterday by Pew Internet and American Life Project found that even if high-speed Internet service was available to the entire nation, about one-third of Americans not currently using broadband still wouldn't because of the expense.
The report was based on two surveys of 4,254 people last year and illustrates a potential hang-up in President Obama's goal to bring broadband Internet to rural and other under served areas: If they build it, it's not clear that people will come.
Will the same apply to regional Australia? The Rudd government has been pushing a rollout to 98% of households and business in Australia, which could add significant cost to the rollout. If only a 66% take up is achieved can the networks be rollout out and achieve its financial goals. In my opinion the target should have been 87% which would have covered the top 50 cities in Australia.
"There are multiple reasons why people don't have broadband, and the hope is that if you are a policymaker you would take away from this report that a focus on availability and price will only get you part of the way there," said John Horrigan, an associate director of research at the Pew project and author of the report.
The nonprofit group One Economy has urged lawmakers to include provisions in a stimulus plan that would renovate public housing so that all units in a building would have access to a shared data network, thereby reducing monthly costs per home by several dollars a month. Rey Ramsey, chief executive of One Economy, said prices of about $10 or less per month is the threshold for greater adoption.
The Information Technology and Innovation Foundation has recently reviewed the OECD statistics on Broadband rankings and created their own composite measure which sits Australia in twelth position. At first look not too bad, but upon further investigation there is some very worrying indicators.
The composite measure takes into account three indicators: household broadband penetration, average speed weighted by percentage of subscribership (Mbps), and lowest available price per Mbps.
While our household penetration is very good ranking us in ninth place, and our pricing is excellent with a ranking of sixth; its our average speed which is of most concern. Of the thirty OECD nations which take part in the Broadband rankings, we are ranking twenty sixth on speed, just above Mexico, Greece and Spain.
What is most worrying is the state of the NBN proposals from the major players, and their continued focus on FTTN. Back in April I wrote an article on the Myth of FTTN and how the current proposals would not meet the performance targets announced by the Government in their 2007 strategic paper and policy launch. More importantly those proposals will not keep Australia competitive in terms of the Digital Economy. To achieve a competitive performance target of 50/12Mbps every home would need to be within 500 metres of a node. If that were achieved today the bandwidth would put us third on the OECD list. However, the current proposals are for every home to be within 1500 metres of a node, giving subscribers an average speed of 18/2Mbps.
If you look at the bandwidth growth over the past 3 years, by the time we start to roll the NBN the top 5 (currently Japan, Korea, Finland, France and Sweden) will be well passed our MAXIMUM capacity, and the top 15 (USA, Denmark, Netherlands, Norway, Switzerland, Greece, Iceland) will most likely be passed that point with their rapid growth in FTTH deployment.
One only has to look at the USA where 2 years ago their average speed was 1.5Mbps. They now are averaging close to 8Mbps. Back then the MAXIMUM speed on offer was 20Mbps on either cable, copper or Fibre. However Verizon through their FiOS product is now offering 100Mbps in some areas and the number of connected customers has doubled. Even the MSOs have doubled their speed offerings (abet introducing download limits) in that same time, and the upgrade to DOCSIS 3.0 is only just starting. My prediction for the USA is within 2 years their average will be 30-40Mbps.
So much for being competitive in the Global Digital Economy.
The composite measure takes into account three indicators: household broadband penetration, average speed weighted by percentage of subscribership (Mbps), and lowest available price per Mbps.
While our household penetration is very good ranking us in ninth place, and our pricing is excellent with a ranking of sixth; its our average speed which is of most concern. Of the thirty OECD nations which take part in the Broadband rankings, we are ranking twenty sixth on speed, just above Mexico, Greece and Spain.
What is most worrying is the state of the NBN proposals from the major players, and their continued focus on FTTN. Back in April I wrote an article on the Myth of FTTN and how the current proposals would not meet the performance targets announced by the Government in their 2007 strategic paper and policy launch. More importantly those proposals will not keep Australia competitive in terms of the Digital Economy. To achieve a competitive performance target of 50/12Mbps every home would need to be within 500 metres of a node. If that were achieved today the bandwidth would put us third on the OECD list. However, the current proposals are for every home to be within 1500 metres of a node, giving subscribers an average speed of 18/2Mbps.
If you look at the bandwidth growth over the past 3 years, by the time we start to roll the NBN the top 5 (currently Japan, Korea, Finland, France and Sweden) will be well passed our MAXIMUM capacity, and the top 15 (USA, Denmark, Netherlands, Norway, Switzerland, Greece, Iceland) will most likely be passed that point with their rapid growth in FTTH deployment.
One only has to look at the USA where 2 years ago their average speed was 1.5Mbps. They now are averaging close to 8Mbps. Back then the MAXIMUM speed on offer was 20Mbps on either cable, copper or Fibre. However Verizon through their FiOS product is now offering 100Mbps in some areas and the number of connected customers has doubled. Even the MSOs have doubled their speed offerings (abet introducing download limits) in that same time, and the upgrade to DOCSIS 3.0 is only just starting. My prediction for the USA is within 2 years their average will be 30-40Mbps.
So much for being competitive in the Global Digital Economy.
According to Martin Mellor an expert in the field of DSL and head of Ericsson’s Fixed Broadband division, FTTN is the right technology for Australia’s National Broadband Network as it would eventually be possible to deliver connection speeds of more than 100Mbps without having to replace all the copper that has provided our telephone connections for decades and more recently ADSL and ADSL2+ services.
As an opening, I would suggest this is a slightly “biased” statement from an equipment vendor who is only trying to push their product; certainly not one from an independent industry expert. Ericsson has predominately delivered copper and wireless based products and only recently gained their fibre technology with the acquisition of Entersphere (GPON) and Marconi (DWDM, SDH, MSAN).
In a statement by Mr Mellor who visited Australia last week, "We think VDSL2 is a great step forward from ADSL2+ but we don't think that's the end of life for copper". He further added "There's too much copper buried in the ground and operators [like Telstra] want to make that sweat, and there's always new technologies that are looking to take advantage of that."
Mr Mellor said Ericsson was working on an enhancement to VDSL technology called Dynamic Spectrum Management – which was actually theorised by an Australian PhD student at Melbourne University - that would increase maximum speeds up towards 250Mbps. However we would have to wait at least three years before it became publicly available technology.
"That's in theory, but in practice we see 50% to 60% of that being achieved in a real network, given copper quality, noise, disturbance on the lines, etc," he said. I wonder if Mr Mellor has seen the state of Telstra copper network lately and the frequent use of the plastic bag for fix up jobs.
According to Mellor, about 30,000 nodes would be required to deliver the required performance. However by my calculations at least 37,500 nodes would be needed to meet the 98% coverage figure and only if the government waters down their promised 12Mbps symmetrical minimum. As previously published on this blog, a VDSL2 node would need to be installed within 750 metres of every home to deliver the required (minimum) 12Mbps upstream due to the limitations of the copper and upstream power capabilities of VDSL2 and midspan cross talk.
Further commenting on the nodes, Mellor said "The thing to think about with these cabinets is that they're going to be deployed on people's doorsteps (and) consideration really needs to be given to … how these devices need to be very low power, otherwise you're going to be turning these into giant heaters for people and have to have lots of fans”. The problem is the nodes do require large amounts of power (17Mwatts across the country) and a node every 750m creates visual pollution. Add to this the batteries and an environmental hazard is just waiting to happen.
According to the FTTH council Europe, who engaged Price Waterhouse Coopers (PWC) to conduct a study on the environmental impact of FTTH, it is the most environmentally friend broadband technology available today.
As an opening, I would suggest this is a slightly “biased” statement from an equipment vendor who is only trying to push their product; certainly not one from an independent industry expert. Ericsson has predominately delivered copper and wireless based products and only recently gained their fibre technology with the acquisition of Entersphere (GPON) and Marconi (DWDM, SDH, MSAN).
In a statement by Mr Mellor who visited Australia last week, "We think VDSL2 is a great step forward from ADSL2+ but we don't think that's the end of life for copper". He further added "There's too much copper buried in the ground and operators [like Telstra] want to make that sweat, and there's always new technologies that are looking to take advantage of that."
Mr Mellor said Ericsson was working on an enhancement to VDSL technology called Dynamic Spectrum Management – which was actually theorised by an Australian PhD student at Melbourne University - that would increase maximum speeds up towards 250Mbps. However we would have to wait at least three years before it became publicly available technology.
"That's in theory, but in practice we see 50% to 60% of that being achieved in a real network, given copper quality, noise, disturbance on the lines, etc," he said. I wonder if Mr Mellor has seen the state of Telstra copper network lately and the frequent use of the plastic bag for fix up jobs.
According to Mellor, about 30,000 nodes would be required to deliver the required performance. However by my calculations at least 37,500 nodes would be needed to meet the 98% coverage figure and only if the government waters down their promised 12Mbps symmetrical minimum. As previously published on this blog, a VDSL2 node would need to be installed within 750 metres of every home to deliver the required (minimum) 12Mbps upstream due to the limitations of the copper and upstream power capabilities of VDSL2 and midspan cross talk.
Further commenting on the nodes, Mellor said "The thing to think about with these cabinets is that they're going to be deployed on people's doorsteps (and) consideration really needs to be given to … how these devices need to be very low power, otherwise you're going to be turning these into giant heaters for people and have to have lots of fans”. The problem is the nodes do require large amounts of power (17Mwatts across the country) and a node every 750m creates visual pollution. Add to this the batteries and an environmental hazard is just waiting to happen.
According to the FTTH council Europe, who engaged Price Waterhouse Coopers (PWC) to conduct a study on the environmental impact of FTTH, it is the most environmentally friend broadband technology available today.
Labels: FTTN
Significant debate has occurred in Australia over the past 2 years regarding the deployment of a Next Generation Network based on Fibre to the Node technology.
In 2003, the Broadband Advisory Group reported that the creation of a ubiquitous “True Broadband Network” would deliver $12-30billion growth in GDP. The definition used for a True Broadband network is one that can deliver a Symmetrical 10Mbps. Why Symmetrical? Because it is the upstream capacity that provides the benefits even our common Internet applications need today. However applications which provide more value to the community that demand the high upstream capabilities include teleworking, video conferencing, eHealth, and Education to mention only a few.
The Myth of FTTN is the belief that it can deliver ubiquitous 12Mbps symmetrical capacity as demanded by the Government in their National Broadband Network policy. Existing FTTN proposals cannot deliver on these Government requirements. Certainly this statement may be seen as contentious but the engineering evidence can certainly back this up.
Today the Annex M extension to ADSL2+ can provide up to 24Mbps in the downstream, but this is significantly dependant on the quality of the copper and distance from the node. However the upstream is limited to a maximum of 3Mbps over short distances, however typical loop lengths see the speed more in the 1.5 – 2Mbps range. Even the new VDSL2 technology – frequently quoted as delivering 100Mbps over copper – cannot deliver symmetrical 12Mbps over the existing copper infrastructure using FTTN.
Previous proposals lodged last year with the former Government where based on the installation of nodes ensuring every home is within a maximum of 1500 metres of Fibre. At this range VDSL2 offers a maximum of 25Mbps downstream and 5Mbps upstream using 24AWG cable. However the current copper deployed within the existing telecommunication network is at best 26AWG and frequently the smaller 28AWG.
We also know there are many bad joints and bridge taps in the aging plant which cause high attenuation, thus reducing the speed even more. These speeds are also based on transmitting at full power. Discussion within the Communication Alliance working group on VDSL2 deployment has suggested lowering transmit power levels at Nodes to lessen the impact of mid-span crosstalk.
The following graph from the DSL forum shows both the downstream and upstream performance of VDSL2. At full power (US 24) using 24AWG cable, VDSL2 can deliver 12Mbps upstream at a maximum distance of 750 metres. Cable based on 26AWG reduces the distance to approximately 600 metres, and 450 metres for 28AWG. These are the best possible distance with minimal attenuation losses caused through bad or corroding joints.
When taking all these issues into account, it will be highly improbable for a FTTN network to meet the 12Mbps Symmetrical speed requirement set by the Government. The only way to get the speeds higher (particularly the upstream) is to push the nodes closer (within 300-500m) to the home and/or to replace the copper. This means more nodes, more cost and more problems (both technical and environmental).
Furthermore while 12Mbps today may be sufficient to meet the immediate demand, the introduction of even a basic application such as IPTV will drive bandwidth demands to greater than 40Mbps. A typical HD television stream is about 14-16Mbps, and if we run multiple channels at the same time (i.e. watch one – record one), we could easily be streaming 25-35Mbps of TV alone.
In 2003, the Broadband Advisory Group reported that the creation of a ubiquitous “True Broadband Network” would deliver $12-30billion growth in GDP. The definition used for a True Broadband network is one that can deliver a Symmetrical 10Mbps. Why Symmetrical? Because it is the upstream capacity that provides the benefits even our common Internet applications need today. However applications which provide more value to the community that demand the high upstream capabilities include teleworking, video conferencing, eHealth, and Education to mention only a few.
The Myth of FTTN is the belief that it can deliver ubiquitous 12Mbps symmetrical capacity as demanded by the Government in their National Broadband Network policy. Existing FTTN proposals cannot deliver on these Government requirements. Certainly this statement may be seen as contentious but the engineering evidence can certainly back this up.
Today the Annex M extension to ADSL2+ can provide up to 24Mbps in the downstream, but this is significantly dependant on the quality of the copper and distance from the node. However the upstream is limited to a maximum of 3Mbps over short distances, however typical loop lengths see the speed more in the 1.5 – 2Mbps range. Even the new VDSL2 technology – frequently quoted as delivering 100Mbps over copper – cannot deliver symmetrical 12Mbps over the existing copper infrastructure using FTTN.
Previous proposals lodged last year with the former Government where based on the installation of nodes ensuring every home is within a maximum of 1500 metres of Fibre. At this range VDSL2 offers a maximum of 25Mbps downstream and 5Mbps upstream using 24AWG cable. However the current copper deployed within the existing telecommunication network is at best 26AWG and frequently the smaller 28AWG.
We also know there are many bad joints and bridge taps in the aging plant which cause high attenuation, thus reducing the speed even more. These speeds are also based on transmitting at full power. Discussion within the Communication Alliance working group on VDSL2 deployment has suggested lowering transmit power levels at Nodes to lessen the impact of mid-span crosstalk.
The following graph from the DSL forum shows both the downstream and upstream performance of VDSL2. At full power (US 24) using 24AWG cable, VDSL2 can deliver 12Mbps upstream at a maximum distance of 750 metres. Cable based on 26AWG reduces the distance to approximately 600 metres, and 450 metres for 28AWG. These are the best possible distance with minimal attenuation losses caused through bad or corroding joints.
When taking all these issues into account, it will be highly improbable for a FTTN network to meet the 12Mbps Symmetrical speed requirement set by the Government. The only way to get the speeds higher (particularly the upstream) is to push the nodes closer (within 300-500m) to the home and/or to replace the copper. This means more nodes, more cost and more problems (both technical and environmental).Furthermore while 12Mbps today may be sufficient to meet the immediate demand, the introduction of even a basic application such as IPTV will drive bandwidth demands to greater than 40Mbps. A typical HD television stream is about 14-16Mbps, and if we run multiple channels at the same time (i.e. watch one – record one), we could easily be streaming 25-35Mbps of TV alone.
Labels: FTTN
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
